Gold ETFs vs Silver ETFs: Difference Between Gold and Silver ETFs
- Updated: 07 Nov 2026, 3:31 PM IST
- | 4m
- 1,001

Gold prices in India have risen sharply over the past few years, putting physical gold out of reach for many retail investors. Silver, trading at a fraction of the price, is now drawing fresh interest from investors, especially through ETFs. But price alone does not decide which metal deserves a place in your portfolio.
Here is how Gold ETFs and Silver ETFs compare on returns, costs and risk.
What are Gold ETFs?
A Gold Exchange-Traded Fund (ETF) is simply a way to buy gold on the stock market. The fund holds physical gold. You only own units of the fund, not the gold itself. If the price of gold in India moves, the value of your ETF investment will change accordingly. You can buy these units through your Demat account, in the same way you buy shares.
What are Silver ETFs?
Silver ETFs are funds that track the price of physical silver. These funds trade on stock exchanges as well. They work like Gold ETFs, except they invest in silver. You can buy and sell units through your trading account, without having to worry about storing silver bars or coins.
Difference Between Gold ETFs and Silver ETFs
Both ETFs may look similar because both let you invest in precious metals through the stock exchange. However, the two metals have different demand drivers. Their price movements and risk levels are different, too.
Factor | Gold ETFs | Silver ETFs |
|---|---|---|
What the fund holds | Physical gold, usually in the form of gold bars. | Physical silver, usually in the form of silver bars. |
What moves the price | Gold prices are influenced by investor demand, jewellery purchases, central bank buying and global uncertainty. | Silver prices respond to investment demand as well as demand from industries that use the metal. |
Where the metal is used | Mostly held as an investment or bought for jewellery. It also has some industrial uses. | Used in products such as solar panels, electronic devices and electric vehicles, apart from jewellery and investment. |
How prices tend to move | Gold prices are generally less volatile and tend to see relatively smaller swings. | Silver prices tend to be more volatile. |
During market uncertainty | Gold is a safe-haven asset. Investors often turn to it when markets are uncertain. | Silver is gaining safe-haven demand. But industrial demand still forms a significant portion. |
Trading activity | Gold ETFs generally have higher trading volumes and a larger market in India. | Trading activity varies across schemes. Some may have lower volumes. |
What one unit costs | Depends on the ETF's current market price. | Depends on the ETF's current market price. |
What it does to your portfolio | Gives exposure to a metal that is often used as a store of value. | Gives exposure to a metal whose price is linked to both precious metal demand and industrial activity. |
Gold ETFs vs Silver ETFs: Returns Delivered
Let us look at the average returns reported by Value Research as of 03 November 2026.
Gold ETF Returns
Gold ETFs delivered an average return of 15.79% over one year and 30.58% over three years.
Silver ETF Returns
Silver ETFs delivered higher average returns of 25.04% over one year and 35.96% over three years.
Silver has outperformed gold over both periods. One reason could be the growing demand for silver from industries. Investor interest in precious metals may have also helped. But silver is also subject to fluctuations. Over three months, Gold ETFs fell 3.86%, while Silver ETFs dropped by a much steeper 17.04%. Silver prices are usually more sensitive to market conditions. So, while silver has delivered better returns in these periods, it has also seen bigger falls along the way.
Gold ETFs vs Silver ETFs: Costs, Liquidity And Taxation
Before choosing between the two, it is worth looking beyond returns. The costs involved, how easily you can trade them, and the tax you pay can also affect what you finally earn.
Costs
Both Gold ETFs and Silver ETFs charge an expense ratio for managing the fund. You may also pay brokerage and other applicable transaction charges when buying or selling units. Compare the expense ratios of different schemes, but do not make your decision on this cost alone.
Liquidity
Both types of ETFs are listed on stock exchanges and can be traded during market hours. However, trading activity can vary from one scheme to another. Some ETFs may have low trading volumes or a wide gap between buying and selling prices. You may not get the price you expect in such cases.
Taxation
Gold ETFs and Silver ETFs are treated as non-equity investments for tax purposes. If you sell your units within 12 months, your gains are generally taxed as per your income tax slab. If you hold them for more than 12 months, the gains are taxed at 12.5%, without indexation.
How to Choose Between Gold ETFs and Silver ETFs
So, how do you decide which one belongs in your portfolio? Start with what you expect from the investment rather than looking only at which metal has performed better recently.
Assess Your Risk Tolerance
Do you prefer relatively stable price movements? If yes, Gold ETFs may be worth a look. If you can handle larger price swings, you might want to take a look at Silver ETFs.
Review Existing Investments
Does your portfolio already have enough exposure to gold? If so, you may want to consider whether adding more of it makes sense. Silver can offer exposure to a different set of demand drivers, particularly industrial demand.
Compare The Schemes Before Investing
Once you decide on the metal, look at the ETF's expense ratio, tracking error and trading volume. Also compare its market price with its indicative NAV (iNAV). This can help you avoid buying units at a significant premium.
Gold ETFs vs Silver ETFs: a Comparative View for Investors
There is no single winner here. Gold may suit investors looking for relatively lower volatility. Silver on the other hand, may appeal to investors seeking more affordable entry points. The metal also offers exposure to industrial demand as well as investment demand. Look at your financial goals, risk appetite and existing portfolio before deciding how much to invest in either metal.
Gold ETFs vs Silver ETFs FAQs
Not necessarily. Silver ETFs have outperformed Gold ETFs during the last 1-year and 3-year periods in terms of average returns. However, silver fell more sharply during the recent correction. Performance varies over time and is subject to many factors.
The answer to this depends on your objectives, risk tolerance and the stage that you are. If you are a beginner, Gold ETFs may be a more comfortable starting point. They offer more stability than silver. If you want something more affordable, Silver ETFs can also be considered. But you should be prepared for sharper price movements.
Silver is gradually gaining more attention, especially with industries like solar energy and electric vehicles using more of it. Gold, on the other hand, has already had a strong run and is still a favourite when markets get shaky. So, which one makes sense to hold for longer? It really depends on whether you are more comfortable with gold or willing to take the ups and downs that come with silver.
The content in this blog is intended purely for educational purposes. Any securities or mutual funds referenced are illustrative in nature and do not constitute a recommendation or endorsement by Kotak Neo. Investors are encouraged to assess their own financial situation and seek professional advice before making any investment decisions. For compliance T&C and disclaimers, Visit https://www.kotakneo.com/disclaimer
0 people liked this article.








